Auto Insurance

The professionals at McMichael Insurance will work with you to eliminate the confusion that exists when selecting auto insurance.

How much liability protection do I need? What deductible should I have on my vehicle? Which insurer offers the best policy for my particular situation? Our staff of professionals will answer these and other questions you may have, so that you can make an informed decision. We don’t stop at simply giving you the cost for each option, rather, we will help you understand real life situations and how having the right coverage, or lack thereof, could impact your financial well-being and your future.

Start With a Free Custom Quote

Originally, I was not sure I wanted to move to a new agency since I thought my prior agent was meeting my needs. After sitting down with McMichael, I began to realize the thoroughness of what they had to offer. Their ability to dissect our existing coverages resulted in finding we were not covered properly in many aspects of our business. As a result, we moved our existing insurance coverage to McMichael Insurance. I highly recommend McMichael Insurance.
Mark Bassett

Cleveland, OH

I saved 32% on my home and auto insurance!
Maximize your discounts on your auto insurance.

Coverage Types

Collision

Collision coverage pays for damage to your vehicle caused by the colliding of two or more objects. The basic policy pays up to the actual cash value of the insured vehicle at the time of loss.
Speak with a Rep Get a Quote

Customizing Coverage

The need for customizing coverage varies greatly from insurer to insurer. While the industry standard policy provides customizing coverage for all vehicles except pickups or vans, some insurers exclude customizing for all vehicles. Still others may include a small amount, perhaps $1,000. Examples of customizing include, but are not limited to the following: conversion packages, chrome wheels, special paint or lettering, truck caps and running boards. If you have any non-factory items installed in your car, truck or van, please advise your insurance professional so appropriate coverage can be put into place.
Speak with a Rep Get a Quote

Electronic Equipment Coverage (Non-factory)

While the basic auto policy already includes coverage for factory electronic equipment, there is still a need to add coverage for equipment that is installed in a location other than the manufacturer’s designed location. We are able to endorse the basic auto policy to cover this non-factory equipment, including items such as stereos, amplifiers, tape players, compact discs, radar detectors, and mobile phones.
Speak with a Rep Get a Quote

Liability
Liability protects you for your legal responsibility, and resulting lawsuits, caused by an automobile accident. The protection afforded by this coverage includes bodily injuries to another person or persons and/or damage to property.

The importance of selecting the right amount of coverage cannot be understated. The law requires the responsible party to make restitution for damages in the form of cash payments. If you do not have enough insurance to pay for the judgment against you, you will be personally responsible to pay the excess amount out of your own pocket. If you are unable to do that from your current earnings then a judgment against your future earnings may be assessed.
Speak with a Rep Get a Quote

Loan/Lease Gap Coverage
While the standard insurance policy pays for the actual cash value of the vehicle, at the time of loss, there are instances where you may owe more than the standard insurance covers. A lease of a vehicle, or sometimes even a loan, will result in a contractual obligation that requires payment of more than the vehicle’s actual cash value, thereby leaving a shortage between what the insurance pays and what the bank requires you to pay. Lease/Loan Gap coverage provides payment for this difference so that you are not stuck paying this out of your own pocket.
Speak with a Rep Get a Quote
Medical Payments
Medical Payments provides an amount of money available to pay for automobile related injuries to you or passengers of your insured vehicle.
Speak with a Rep Get a Quote
Other than Collision (Comprehensive)
This coverage provides payment for damage to your insured vehicle caused by a Comprehensive loss, sometimes termed Other-Than-Collision. Typical examples of claims falling into this category include fire, theft, vandalism, malicious mischief and breakage of a windshield. Collision with a bird or animal is also classified as Comprehensive. The basic policy pays up to the actual cash value of the insured vehicle at the time of loss.
Speak with a Rep Get a Quote
Rental Reimbursement
Rental Reimbursement provides payment for rental car use due to a covered loss to your insured vehicle.
Speak with a Rep Get a Quote
Towing and Labor
Towing and Labor coverage will pay up to the limit of coverage purchased in connection with the disablement of your insured vehicle completed at the scene of the disablement. This includes expenses such as towing, roadside fueling of your car, a jump start or battery replacement, and changing a tire.
Speak with a Rep Get a Quote
Uninsured and Underinsured Motorists
Uninsured and Underinsured Motorist provides payment for bodily injury to you or passengers involved in an auto accident which is caused by a driver with either no insurance (uninsured motorists) or not enough insurance (underinsured motorists). This coverage may also apply to bodily injury to an insured household member, caused by an uninsured or underinsured motorist while riding in a non-household vehicle, walking, or riding a bike.
Speak with a Rep Get a Quote
Uninsured Motorist Property Damage
Uninsured Motorist Property Damage pays for damage to your vehicle in the event that it is struck by a positively identified underinsured motorist. If you insure your vehicle for full coverage, the collision coverage will pay for your vehicles. If you do not carry collision coverage, or you carry high deductibles, Uninsured Motorist Property Damage is a good option to protect your vehicle from damage caused by a driver with no insurance. This coverage is subject to a $250 deductible.
Speak with a Rep Get a Quote

Other Insurances

Our Customers

Saved money on car insurance!
Robert Wallerstein
Robert Wallerstein
13:42 14 May 24
Sherry Barnes was great and super helpful. Very informative and professional and answered all questions.
Diana Lopez
Diana Lopez
13:39 30 Apr 24
Great customer service!
Roberrt C
Roberrt C
22:00 18 Apr 24
I have been with McMichael Insurance for many years. Great service. Faith Recchion is my go to agent.
Cheryl DeCavitch
Cheryl DeCavitch
18:30 17 Apr 24
Sherry has been wonderful in finding me the best and most affordable insurance coverage! Terrific company!
Donnamarie
Donnamarie
14:01 17 Apr 24
We received great service.
Dave T
Dave T
13:58 17 Apr 24
Dennis McMichael is expert in the field of insurance; he knows the details and applies them to the best interest of our family: understanding our needs and applying solutions is a skill set he has and I don't. This seems like a simple problem but its not. One has got to TRUST the judgement of one's agent: fully and completely. In this regard Dennis, and the McMichael team are the best in the business in crafting packages to meet needs. In our case it is a package of home, auto, health, and umbrella policies which interact to provide an effective shield against disaster and improve day-to-day living. Over time the team has helped us make changes to improve our evolving coverage requirements. The McMichael team are always ready to answer questions and provide suggestions; mostl importantly, we are never alone.
Thomas Mlinar
Thomas Mlinar
14:28 16 Apr 24
Great Experience with Dennis. Was able to save us a significant amount on our insurance. We were also able to increase our coverage, and still have savings versus what our current insurance company was charging. Will definitely be referring business to them.
Mary Bezzeg
Mary Bezzeg
13:51 16 Apr 24
I have been dealing with Faith Recchion at McMichael Insurance. Her communication has been very professional and response to all inquiries has been in a timely fashion. Found me the best rates for home and car year after year.
Greg Pastor
Greg Pastor
22:01 02 Apr 24
Best insurance experience I have had!I love that they send you a video of their proposal and explain everything!Not too bad that they found me the best rates as well!
Tony L Orth
Tony L Orth
23:43 01 Apr 24
Have been a client for decades. Never will choose another company.
Tara Centea
Tara Centea
20:44 28 Mar 24
Dennis was incredibly helpful and efficient in helping me get in contact with my insurance adjuster. He responded immediately to my concerns and was friendly and understanding of my frustration. He went to bat on my behalf and got results immediately. Thanks Dennis!
Sarah Jeppesen
Sarah Jeppesen
03:10 28 Mar 24
I really appreciate their help and orientation, they take the time to answer all your questions and overall, it's a great option to get your insurance from!!
Juan Rivera
Juan Rivera
19:21 23 Mar 24
Great attention and willingness to help find the best option for me!
Antonio Rivera
Antonio Rivera
18:16 13 Mar 24
Wonderful to work with! I would highly recommend!
Ashley Hendricks
Ashley Hendricks
17:55 12 Mar 24
My customer needs have always been exceeded in working with Dennis McMichael. His experience is such a plus and I always feel protected with the best possible insurance solutions to needs. He is prompt and follows up on everything. At the same time, I have always saved money in working with his business relations! Dennis McMichael is old school and truly believes in follow up.
Terry Stilla
Terry Stilla
12:01 12 Mar 24
Sherry is absolutely amazing! She went through all of my policies and found the best matches for my needs and saved me money! She was very thorough, knowledgeable and got back to me quickly. 10/10 recommend!
Tiffany Yanulaitis
Tiffany Yanulaitis
13:56 07 Mar 24
McMichael Insurance works hard for their clients. Any and every time I called with a question or statement, they answered it promptly. They all were very helpful. The office staff was interested in in the client as a person as well. My wife and I are very pleased with McMichael Insurance.
Dan and Lisa Fouser
Dan and Lisa Fouser
21:35 01 Mar 24
Working with Kathryn and Brian made the switch to McMichael simple and flawless. They took the time to explain things we didn't understand and to make sure we had the coverage we need. My favorite part about working with McMichael Insurance is the additional benefits like online training, tips, tools and webinars that ensure my staff is up to date on current policies and trends that could affect our small nonprofit in Columbiana County.
Chaney Nezbeth
Chaney Nezbeth
13:37 01 Mar 24
Faith was wonderful! Found me the best deal on the market. Thanks!
Marcus Still
Marcus Still
18:46 28 Feb 24
always very helpful at answering questions and resolving issues on telephone the first time.
Harold Redman
Harold Redman
16:41 19 Feb 24
The service and expertise Sherry provided was amazing. She really worked hard to find us/get us the best quote! Really pleased to change carriers and to now work with McMichaels.
Joshua Ralston
Joshua Ralston
18:28 15 Feb 24
Dennis was so helpful and patient! He took time to answer all my questions and made sure I understand all the coverage changes I wanted to make. I appreciate all of his help and going out of his way to assist me in setting up my new insurance! So thankful for a caring company!
Alyssa Nagy
Alyssa Nagy
16:41 15 Feb 24
Dealt with Debbie, Brian and Dennis on multiple policies. Excellent service. Subject matter experts in the field. Difference between them other past agents, was that they asked questions on things I didn't even know to ask to ensure I was properly insured with proper amounts. Understood my needs. Having been through the Hurricane experience, I understand the importance of good policy/companies. Many INSUR companies will take your money but won't pay out or support you when times comes. Fortunately, in FL, I had great INSUR company. My point? Definitely want educated agents who are experts and honest. Hands down, best service I ever had, and I was with USAA for 27 yrs. Thank you and appreciate excellent customer service. Definitely recommending them to my family and friends.
Sonny Veteran1
Sonny Veteran1
15:55 15 Feb 24
the coverage they found me was apples to apples to the former company i had at half the cost. A 50% savings a year is a great help pushing retirement years. Thanks again McMichael Insurance.
John Gerard
John Gerard
14:53 13 Feb 24
Sherry was great to work with and very knowledgeable about the products and recommendations. I highly recommend her and McMichael Insurance if you are looking to get the best service and price.
john brown
john brown
14:20 12 Feb 24
Sherry is a very knowledgeable and pleasant person. I could not have asked for a better resource for my insurance needs. Thanks.
Rod Reamer
Rod Reamer
13:03 09 Feb 24
Absolutely best company around!
Ashley Teeple
Ashley Teeple
19:33 07 Feb 24
They make things easy
Pat Minotti
Pat Minotti
14:38 07 Feb 24
Agents are always pleasant and helpful and are available to answer questions. There were no issues with my most recent claim experience. I would recommend McMichael Insurance for all your insurance needs.
April Woodland
April Woodland
21:21 04 Feb 24
I needed to get some new quotes and Faith at Mcmichaels went above and beyond at getting me what I needed for insurance. She listened to me and it was a pleasure to work with her.
John Seaburn
John Seaburn
22:42 01 Feb 24
McMichael Insurance has helped me with my insurance needs for home, auto and watercraft for many years. Whenever I need assistance, I always find them to be kind, professional and thoroughly knowledgeable. They communicate well and follow through with their commitments. I greatly appreciate the partnership we’ve built over the years.
Scott & Jeri Clark
Scott & Jeri Clark
14:59 01 Feb 24
I've used McMichael for about 20 years now. They have always gone above and beyond to make sure my questions are answered, and I have the appropriate coverage.
Dan Kort
Dan Kort
02:49 01 Feb 24
Sherry is great to work with. Patient and very knowledgeable.
YOUR DENTAL HYGIENIST
YOUR DENTAL HYGIENIST
14:38 29 Jan 24
Sherry was very helpful through the process and helped us secure insurance for our investment property on such short notice. Thank you
One Family One Home
One Family One Home
15:43 24 Jan 24
Can't thank enough to Mark for helping me with the perfect home insurance which is cost effective and covers everything I was looking for.Thanks.
Samir Hasan
Samir Hasan
14:54 22 Jan 24
We have held our insurance (home, auto and life) through McMichael Insurance for quite a few years upon recommendation from our financial advisor. They are not only honest and helpful but empathic and relatable. Over the years I have had various insurance questions and concerns, and never once have I hesitated to call them. I never feel rushed or leave the conversation feeling like I didn't have my question answered. They are patient as well as reliable. Most recently I have had to file a claim and Dennis was more than willing to take the time to walk me through the process as well as offer personalized advice on the details of how to handle things going forward. I even received a follow up phone call today checking to make sure the process was going smoothly. I couldn't ask for any better service and would highly recommend McMichael Insurance.
hon350
hon350
00:56 19 Jan 24
Excellent communication and response
James Scoby
James Scoby
14:14 18 Jan 24
They got me a great policy with a wonderful price!
TROY TOMCZAK
TROY TOMCZAK
22:29 17 Jan 24
A wonderful experience, wish it were free . . .
William
William
15:22 11 Jan 24
I feel that Dennis did a wonderful job he was able to negotiate me a really good price on my insurance.
Rochelle Ford
Rochelle Ford
14:27 09 Jan 24
Sherry was so nice! Fantastic! Highly recommend.
Kelly Ward
Kelly Ward
14:31 08 Jan 24
Sherry was wonderful at finding me the best rate with the most coverage. She was very friendly and prompt with the contract. I highly recommend McMichael.
Renee Davidson
Renee Davidson
14:15 27 Dec 23
Dennis McMichael and Melissa Carr are exceptional. They helped me to navigate through all of my changes. When I left a message I was promptly called back. Great Company & Great people.
John Mcmahon
John Mcmahon
17:42 21 Dec 23
Best insurance! They were able to provide me good home insurance. Recommend Sherry Barnes
Sohee Moon
Sohee Moon
20:15 18 Dec 23
The most amazing service and staff!!!
Michael Mariana II
Michael Mariana II
14:54 12 Dec 23
Sherry Barnes at McMichael Insurance was most helpful in finding home and auto insurance that met our needs and budget. She not only found much better coverage than our previous policies but premiums that are substantially less than what we have been paying. We are glad we contacted McMichael Insurance.
Chip Lago
Chip Lago
18:26 11 Dec 23
Great to work with Sherry!
Kirk Manton
Kirk Manton
14:48 07 Dec 23
Dennis McMichael is an excellent insurance agent that works exclusively to help his clients save money and receive the best coverage available.
Don Garrini
Don Garrini
20:58 06 Dec 23
Dennis and the staff were very thorough and professional and they seemed genuinely interested in my satisfaction. I would highly recommend them for all your insurance needs.
Tom Scudiere
Tom Scudiere
19:23 28 Nov 23
I have been with McMichael for many years now and they have always taken care of my needs. Debbie Craft is amazing to work with. I spent over an hour on the phone with her asking question after question and she never tired. She never gave the sense that it was time to move on to the next customer. She followed up when she said she would and delivered just as she said she would. She saved me over $1,000/year. Extremely pleased customer here.
Don Giddens
Don Giddens
16:58 26 Nov 23
My insurance agent was unavailable-so glad Debbie Craft took my call!. After hearing that my hail damage claim was rejected, she immediatly put me through to her superviser who came to my home to discuss the claim. Thanks to Debbie's initial intervention, I ended up receiving a substantial sum. She also got me a fantastic deal on insurance for my antique car. In both cases her actions were imediate-effeciency should be her middle name!
stew langenbeck
stew langenbeck
17:44 21 Nov 23
We have had insurance with them since the 1990's.
Janice Miller
Janice Miller
14:35 21 Nov 23
Thank you for staying on top of my policies and your easy professionalism.
Robin L. Brower
Robin L. Brower
15:07 17 Nov 23
Dennis and Dawn are amazing to work with. One hopes to never need to file an insurance claim but when it is necessary, I would not want to have to navigate the situations without an advocate! For example, on one occasion, I was rear-ended on the freeway in Columbus during rush hour. When I called the police, I was told that since the vehicles were drivable, no officer would be dispatched. Not knowing what to do, I called my insurance agent, Dennis. Dennis talked with both the other driver and me to document all the necessary information to file the claim. Who does that?? Well, MY insurance agent does that!!And Dawn is a problem solver! When our mortgage was sold to another company, there was a lot of confusion between the banks and our insurance premiums were paid to the wrong bank. Dawn spent a lot of time working through those details to clean up a mess that wasn't of her doing!People will often tell me that they like buying insurance directly without using an agent. For me, that's not an avenue I wish to take. I want the benefit of knowing I have a group of people ready to intervene when (not "if") life happens!
Kim McNamara
Kim McNamara
21:30 16 Nov 23
Sherry Barnes at McMichael Insurance is just superb. She’s attentive, knowledgeable and very friendly. Im now paying HALF of what I was paying for home and auto insurance!
Stunt Cat
Stunt Cat
15:02 16 Nov 23
worked with Sherry. after several phone calls/emails, I ended up buying new policies via her. Saved some $ vs. auto renewal with another mainstream insurance company.
David Chen
David Chen
15:32 15 Nov 23
Very responsive
Jeremy Rentz
Jeremy Rentz
14:14 15 Nov 23
I'm a new customer with McMichael Insurance, transferring from a long-standing relationship with another agent. Making the switch to McMichael's was difficult because of my prior relationship with my tried-and-true agent, but had to be done due to shifts in the market and our needs. Dennis worked with me so thoroughly and with such empathy and patience that I felt I was moving from one caring agency to another. I felt understood and held very competently by Dennis and his team. A big thanks for helping us on this new journey!!
Dave Schrader
Dave Schrader
17:14 14 Nov 23
Professional service . Excellent!!
Benoy Michael
Benoy Michael
15:58 13 Nov 23
Brian was very attentive, delivered exactly what we were looking for!
joel orellana
joel orellana
14:24 13 Nov 23
New client. JimGreat experience!
Greg Theirl
Greg Theirl
14:28 10 Nov 23
It is always a pleasant experience working with the McMichaels. They explain everything thoroughly and there is never any pressure.
Ginny Curran
Ginny Curran
21:13 09 Nov 23
Sherry is very friendly and extremely helpful and knowledgeable.
Martin Carlton
Martin Carlton
17:21 08 Nov 23
All my questions are answered quickly and expertly. Their advice has always proved to be trustworthy. They are kind and eager to be helpful.
Sheryl Buckley
Sheryl Buckley
21:26 02 Nov 23
McMichael Insurance has provided our company many years of exceptional service. The whole team at McMichael Insurance has been outstanding. Kathryn Wolf (Senior Mgr),our Acct Mgr, and has been nothing but superb. You will be more than satisfied with the quality of service this agency provides.
Jeff Judd
Jeff Judd
19:27 31 Oct 23
Dennis is super quick to respond and very helpful! A+ in my book! He is definitely in my "CIRCLE OF TRUST" when it comes to professionals!
J M
J M
19:11 30 Oct 23
Sherry was very helpful and charming with getting our home and auto insurance set up. We appreciate her hard work and look forward to working with McMichael Insurance.
Joe Howell
Joe Howell
16:26 27 Oct 23
Sherry was incredibly helpful in explaining all options and coverages. She even took time to give suggestions based on best possible value. I couldn't be happier with the coverage she found me.
Jared Markwald
Jared Markwald
20:13 18 Oct 23
Great prices on insurance, helpful and friendly customer service !!
Roger RogerM
Roger RogerM
16:46 17 Oct 23
I like dealing with an agent vs. a website andSherry did a great job setting up insurance for my car.
Thomas Pawlik
Thomas Pawlik
13:47 12 Oct 23
If I could rate in half stars, I would say 4.5 stars. Sherry was professional and found a good deal on my bundled insurance. Would recommend.
Daniel Kopinsky
Daniel Kopinsky
22:21 11 Oct 23
I have been with them for years. Excellent people. They have always taken good care of us. They don't play games and sell you stuff you don't need. Very honest, fair, and knowledgeable, so why go anywhere else? Thank you!
Michael Decker
Michael Decker
23:30 06 Oct 23
Everything I needed and more! This company is amazing and they make amazing things happen!! Will be using for a very long time!
McMichael Insurance saved my husband & I thousands of dollars on insurance for our home, vehicles and farm compared to our previous provider. Their staff is very professional, friendly & knowledgeable. I would & have recommended them to friends & my own real estate clients.
Darlene Kearney
Darlene Kearney
21:34 04 Oct 23
Although I haven't had any issues to require me to utilize the insurance, I am very pleased with the communication and setup process Sherry walked me through. Honestly, she did all the hard work. Very appreciative for her making the homeowners insurance (and car insurance) process a breeze while I was busy working on buying a home.
Kate Macko
Kate Macko
16:02 03 Oct 23
Sherry was very professional and courteous took really good care of me and got me the best deal
Jamie Fleming
Jamie Fleming
15:12 26 Sep 23
I had a great experience working with Dennis throughout the entire insurance process as I had 3 policies up for review. He promptly answered any questions and suggested some great changes. I received a double benefit: better coverage at a significantly lower cost. The whole staff is top notch and handles changes quickly and professionally. I highly recommend McMichael Insurance for all your insurance needs. 5 stars!
J Stach
J Stach
01:53 26 Sep 23
Working with Dennis has been such a great experience! He called right away when I sent in an online request for information and answered every single question. Dennis saved us so much money with MORE coverage! I am so glad that we found McMichael Insurance. I highly suggest them to anyone and everyone I talk to now. Call them now and see what they can offer for you!
Jessica Boyer
Jessica Boyer
13:14 13 Sep 23
js_loader

Get a Free Quote

More Options. More Savings.