Refer a Friend, Get Rewarded!
When you refer a friend or family member, we will send you a Gift Card as a thank you once we do a policy review.
- 330-626-4972
- Get a Quote
- Payments / Claims
- Google Rating5.0Based on 912 reviews
McMichael Insurance5.0
Mckenzie Mobley15:38 24 Aug 26McMichael Insurance was excellent to work with. They made shopping for the best price and coverage simple. They also made the transaction easy.Kristen Light13:17 24 Jul 26Great people to work with. Kelsey has been such a big help and is very knowledgeable. Thank you!Paul Moore13:42 01 Jun 26Brian was very present and attentive during the onboarding process. They handled our client with great care and professionalism.C Herritt13:47 11 May 26Very easy to work with. Made sure I understood all about the insurance products they had to offer, even included videos. 100% recommend.Kevin14:22 29 Apr 26Great experience working with Kelsey, she was able to get us into a cheaper rate for both my home and auto.Alana Vaughn19:33 07 Apr 26Kelsey has made this switch of insurance so smooth, and she has been so efficient in every aspect. I also love the fact that I can call and talk directly to their team if I were... to need anything; this was not the case before for me. I would HIGHLY recommend working with this team.read moreLia Motta18:24 31 Mar 26Kelsey was awesome! She was very knowledgeable, friendly, and very quick to respond to any questions I had!Kevin Gerber16:39 16 Mar 26They talked me through the different options for home owners insurance and helped me make an informed decision.Dragana Trifkovic17:24 13 Mar 26Working with Kelsey Mattson was great. She assisted me with a good home insurance policy.Travis Ressler17:16 13 Mar 26Kelseywas friendly, informative, and helpful. I received slightly better coverage at a reduced rate. What more can you ask for?Maureen Lancione14:48 11 Mar 26Josh was very helpful, thorough and informative. He made the transition to Medicare pretty seamless. He was also very prompt in all his responses.John Clegg14:40 11 Mar 26Chris did an unbelievable job for our family. In a matter of 2 months, we went from 4 drivers on 2 different policies, to a great new price for 3 drivers on one policy, with our... daughter moving off our policy and our son added to our policy with a new car. Chris and all the agents who answered calls were always helpful, expert, and got us better pricing every time. Just like in Real Estate having an agency working for you, and an agent like Chris gets you the best deal! Thanks Chris! Thanks McMichael Insurance!!read moreErin Bossler01:32 06 Mar 26Josh at McMichael Insurance was super helpful! He was super responsive, answered all our questions, and was able to help us find insurance to save $600/year! We had a great... experience and would highly recommend them!read moreKendra05:04 26 Feb 26Kelsey made setting up my homeowners insurance a breeze. She handled everything effortlessly, even though I took longer than expected to respond to her calls and emails. Despite... my delayed responses, she remained prompt, friendly, and ensured that all my questions were answered.read moreRandy Smoot22:46 20 Feb 26McMichael Insurance Agency has been excellent to work with. Their team is professional, responsive, and knowledgeable. They’ve made managing our homeowners, umbrella, and auto... policies with Hanover Insurance simple and stress-free. Highly recommended!read moreFran Leck14:15 19 Feb 26Been with McMichael for 15 years. Always great customer service. Have and continue to recommend them.mark moore17:36 13 Feb 26We had this company quote our Home and Auto and they were so quick and attentive to detail we had them quote 3 other policies for us. They won them all, and we won!Kelsey Mattson... is wonderful to work with, ask for her!read moreScott Roop14:21 30 Jan 26Justin B was great through the whole process of looking for insurance for my company. He was very transparent and got me the coverage i needed.Aaron Reynolds17:16 19 Jan 26Great experience with Dennis. Was able to upgrade our auto, home, condo policies and add an umbrella policy for the same cost as previous insurer.Mike Foster17:30 12 Jan 26Great experience. Kelsey was the best.I was looking for a local agent that I can do business with. Glad I found them.Cathy Petricevic11:46 06 Jan 26Gerald was extremely helpful and patient with us as we changed insurance companies after years of being with a large well known national company. He saved us money and got us even... better coverage. Win win!read moreDan Goodhart15:11 30 Dec 25Have been a loyal customer of McMichael’s for well over 35 years. There service is well beyond the normal company and I would never think of changing and would recommend to allZachary Churchill14:08 23 Dec 25My wife and I really enjoy working with McMichael Insurance. They saved us some money and it is comforting to know that we have some we can talk to if we run into issues and need... help. They are extremely professional and deliver exceptional customer service. I would highly recommend them to anyone!read moreJ Jaroniec14:13 15 Dec 25Josh was very professional and kind. He saved me lots of money and time finding the good health insurance. Doing business with him was very rewarding.Kara Oster15:59 05 Dec 25McMichael Insurance had be up and running with insurance before my new car was even ready to be driven off the lot! Kelsey was great to work with. Very efficient and they got me... and even better deal than what I had before. Excellent experience and highly recommend!read moreMegan Colby14:12 03 Dec 25We had a great experience working with Kelsey M. At McMichaels's insurance! She was quick to respond to our questions and working with her to compare quotes & choose the right... home & auto plan was really smooth.read moreStacy Rippey15:17 09 Nov 25I appreciate the guidance & follow through to help cover our needs during a difficult time.Alan Ramsey14:22 07 Nov 25I was referred to McMichael Insurance by a very reputable financial planning company and the results did not disappoint. After an analysis of our previous policies, we were... offered better coverage at a lower cost. The advisors were very accommodating and helpful and they made it easy to make the switch.read moreBob R13:59 05 Nov 25McMichael Insurance reached to us for several years to ask if there was anything they could offer us, when it was time for us to ask, they delivered and did a great job.chuck Famageltto17:25 04 Nov 25Josh was an excellent help with my medical advantage plan. Thank you again JoshMichael Johnson15:23 21 Oct 25Business Insurance - Great follow up and a great help when needing guidance starting my business and what insurance to getWm Hiner12:45 21 Oct 25You worked hard to get us a good deal on the insurance and you were patient with us in communicating the policy.Thanks again, Bill and Pat.Kelly Byrnes15:13 17 Sep 25Kelsey was through, efficient and friendly and also will be saving me over a $1k a year.kurt kluznik14:03 17 Sep 25McMichael has been an excellent value added resource to us. THey have taken the time to learn about our business. Reviewing contracts, bonding, and getting involved with sub... contractors has been very helpful.read moreLarry-Janet Sampson19:31 07 Sep 25Very easy to work with, found insurance at lower rates than we currently pay.Jason P18:11 03 Sep 25Kelsey was so helpful in setting up our homeowners’ insurance and auto insurance! We moved here from out of state and didn’t know anyone in the area, so we hoped we would find... someone trustworthy and knowledgeable to help us navigate our insurance needs. Kelsey was always available to answer our questions and give us peace of mind. Thank you Kelsey and McMichael Insurance for helping us find the perfect policies for us! We will definitely use McMichael for all our insurance policies in the future.read moreAbby Fishel16:00 18 Aug 25All went well and we got great new rates---BUT everything is handled electronically including conversations. No personal phone calls to discuss things. I think there was one... phone call to answer some questions but otherwise all was handled over the computer. While I appreciate the expediency-no one there knows us!read moreMichelle Walters14:57 18 Aug 25Joshua provided me with knowledge and resources on choosing my Medicare benefits. He followed up but did not pressure me to decide. He is a great resource!Stacie Pollack14:46 13 Aug 25Amazing to work with, very informative, patient. Went over every detail in great length. Communication was spot on. Staff was very friendly all the way through the process. 5... Stars all the way!read moreDawn Bailey14:10 31 Jul 25Kelsey was an exceptional help to us in getting very prompt, efficient, FULL insurance coverage on a house we just purchased! So kind! So responsive. Better than 5 stars for... certain. I will use her and McMichael insurance for all of my insurance needs that they can cover going forward! Thank you, Kelsey!read morejoe Anderson23:21 25 Jul 25Great communication, thorough, timely and professional.Made the prices seamless and easyThank youJoeRaymond Thomas01:48 19 Jul 25They find me the best policies with little doing on my part except clicking a few signaturesKevin Brown00:01 13 Jul 25My experience working with Joshua has been phenomenal. Me and my wife both worked with him on our Medicare. He explained all the details in layman's terms so that I could make a... informed decision. I would highly recommend him to others for all of your insurance needsread moreRuth Herman13:28 02 Jul 25I was very impressed by the service and would recommend McMichaels Ins. Kealsey, the rep I worked with was very helpful, knowledgeable and pleasant.marlene alborn15:49 20 Jun 25I Think the people at McMichael's insurance are very helpful to their customers. Thank you.Janet Proudfoot13:06 18 Jun 25Okay it was a real one on one experience working with Josh I felt comfortable, I trusted him, and we constantly kept in touch and made me much less nervous about retiring. He is... still keeping in contact with me and I will refer him to all my friends and familyread moreDebra Wessels18:41 13 Jun 25McMichael was recommended by our financial advisors. They took time to look over our current policy and suggest changes where lacking. We increased several of our limits and still... saved a lot. Very happy with our experience.read moreTherese Rucinski19:00 04 Jun 25Josh took the time to answer all our questions and explain the police. He was very helpful! I would recommend him to anyone.Jennifer Statford23:28 15 May 25I have been doing business with McMichael Insurance for too many years to remember and I have always received great friendly service!I would highly recommend them for your... insurance carrier for whatever purpose.read moreRichard Walker13:52 30 Apr 25Very knowledgeable and easy to work with. Looking forward to working with a proactive company.Judy Davidson17:06 27 Mar 25I was looking for another insurance agent and read reviews on agencies in the area and decided to call McMichael Insurance. I was very lucky to get Dennis. He was very helpful... and took his time explaining things to me. I am very happy with my rates and coverage and the excellant service I have received. I told my son to call them because I was so impressed with the help and patience I received from Dennis.read moreMichelle Bahle14:21 26 Mar 25I was looking for new insurance and I reached out to Dennis at McMichael Insurance and he helped me so much! He answered all of my questions and got me better insurance than what... I previously had for a better price. Would highly recommend if you're looking for better insurance than what you have!read moreGINA HOLDERBAUM13:17 26 Mar 25The customer service is outstanding. Any time I’ve had a question or concern, I call them and my questions are answered. I recently was due for a redetermination of my auto and... home owners’ insurance, and Nick found me a much better deal than I had been getting. Outstanding agency to work withread moreClay Howard13:27 25 Mar 25Very imformative. Dennis made sure to really go over all our options. Bottom line, we got better insurance coverage and reduced our costs.John Wirsing13:10 20 Mar 25Dennis McMichael was very knowledgeable and efficient in preparing our insurance package at a price that we were pleased withShelli Lubecky22:06 04 Mar 25Faith got me a much better deal on my home/auto. She was responsive and handled everything quicklySara Karides Phillips14:11 25 Feb 25Dennis and his team were willing to shop around rates for me when I needed a lower rate due to reduced income and because of my clean driving record for several years. His... dedication to making the effort to provide affordable auto insurance for me when I needed it is what is most important to me to retain my loyalty as a client since I am a new customer to this agency. I appreciate his efforts.read moreMario Salwan (The Garage Finisher)03:21 13 Feb 25McMichael Insurance was very thorough in making sure my business and home had proper coverage including Umbrella Policy. In the end I had more insurance coverage than my previous... agency provided and the cost was less.read moreM B21:12 06 Feb 25Excellent customer service, people skills, knowledge, and competitive rates. McMichael was able to lower my premium and the video provided with the quote explaining it all is top... tier! Thank you!read moreMs. Harper14:53 03 Feb 255 stars for clarity, communication, and incredible rates! From first reaching out, McMichael Insurance was incredibly helpful. Dennis made us a video explaining what our quote... actually means. He was super quick to respond to our follow-up questions, adjusting our plan in real time it seemed. We are super happy with their rates and our bundled home & auto!read moreJia Lin00:49 01 Nov 24I have worked with Ms. Faith Recchion, she is very through and quick in reponse. Always answer the calls in a timely fashion and very patient in explaining details to me. Thank... you Faith!read moreSJ L01:34 05 Oct 22McMichael's is truly an amazing Agency to work with. Always prompt, courteous and looking out for your best interest. I have been with them since I started driving about 17 years... ago and they've always gotten me the best available policies at the best prices saving me a lot of $ over time. Highly recommended.read moreMargarita Kornuc15:10 02 Sep 22Tom Masters is simply the best in the business. I recommend him and the McMichael Insurance team to literally everyone I know. Best price I've found on the market for high level,... full-service insurance. Thank you, Tom and team!read moreLoleita Ballard14:53 31 Aug 22I've had this insurance for a couple of years and I really enjoyed the people there everybody is so friendly and professional I would recommend you to friends and familyBarbara Long15:47 27 Jun 22I have had MCMICHAEL Ins.for many, many, years, and they are always ready to help out on a minute's notice and they get thins done for their clients rather quickly, and the... staffis always friendly and they make sure you Re happy with them..read moreelKarlos12:38 16 May 22Long time McMichael customer.I had been living of of the country for several years and kept a motorcycle here to ride when I came back. Karen always had me ready to go.I... recently bought a new car on a Saturday and she even went out of her way to get me insured. She is awesome!Solid, reliable company.read moreIsaiah SonofAmoz15:58 05 May 22Very good agency, always helpful and will search for the best deals. I would recommend this agency to anyone. They always look for the best deal for the customer with multiple... insurance companies they deal with. They do better than the Liberty customization. Give them a try.read moreSue Ann Ray15:18 03 May 22McMichael Insurance Agency is great for us. They were able to help us find an inexpensive way to keep my Mom's Lift Van insured while not in use. I highly recommend McMichael's.Dee Semethy14:52 06 Apr 22It's all good! they have always found the best rates for me, I appreciate that especially with the high cost of living these days!Debbie Pickle22:36 23 Feb 22Thanks so much, great service. My agent Debbie Craft is always very quick to respond and will get me a quote ASAP. Thanks Debbie!Jennifer Peterson08:49 23 Feb 22I've been with McMichael Ins for a while now and Karen is always quick to respond to any questions I have or new needs we need met. She is a pleasure to work with! We have home... and car through them. Definitely recommend!read morePeggy Paskiet16:28 13 Feb 22I have had awesome service with McMichael Insurance. My house and car are both insured through them. My questions are answered promptly and problems are handled right away. Thank... you McMichael Insurance!read moreDakota Marie15:59 26 Dec 21Tom is awesome. Always quick to respond to any question or need that I have. I can't believe the deal I've received on car insurance & I couldn't be happier that I've found... McMichael!!read moreShari Lea16:13 29 Nov 21The team is very responsive in returning my calls and providing me with answers to my questions.Thank you!stew langenbeck22:23 23 Nov 21The McMichael agency did everything thing they possibly could to help me with my hail damage claim denial. Although the claim has yet to be resolved, I wouldn't have known what... steps to take w/o them!read moreMark Kelly18:22 04 Nov 21Insurance Agent Tom Masters is simply the best...we've been using his advice for 15 years!Lisa Holdt19:12 02 Oct 21They are fast and cheaper than going through Progressive. Helped me with house insurance too! Love them. Ask for Julie or Karen.David Harrison15:29 14 Sep 21They have always provided prompt and first class service. I highly recommend them to anyone wanting any type of insurance.Aaron Gonzales13:18 29 Aug 21Helpful, knowledgeable staff helped me find the best overall coverage for all my insurance needs.Les Dykes16:09 30 Jul 21The rates are very competitive and I really like the online scheduling of premium payments.Terrence Duffey14:11 26 Jul 21Assisted me when I needed to get rental insurance at the last minute for my apartment.They have now help me obtain homeowners insurance on my first house purchase. Went with... Grange and bundled my car insurance into it too to get a better rate. I am quite happy with McMichael insurance and would highly recommend them.read moreLeeAnn Bramlett07:38 04 Jun 21I have been using McMichael for my insurance needs for a very long time(about 20 years). I have always received great rates, and have been treated with respect and kindness.Jennifer Blosser02:30 01 Jun 21Karen is the best! She's always so friendly and helpful with any questions or concerns about our policy! Love them!Sam Bluso14:47 28 May 21Courteous and professional service while being very friendly. Responsive. Best insurance team I’ve had over the last 40 years. Glad I switched.Pat Bell14:38 19 May 21McMichael's Insurance has been a great asset to my insurance needs. They are very helpful with any questions you may have.Steve Willoughby14:59 14 Apr 21I've worked with McMichael Insurance for nearly two decades and have always received great service and have felt like they are doing their very best to have us properly covered at... a competitive price. I have sent many referrals there way from friends and family.read moreSt. Stephen Office14:50 14 Apr 21They are always pleasant to work with and very responsive to questions regarding the policy.Eric McKinney16:09 22 Mar 21Great to deal with.. always trying to get you the best coverage for the best priceMatthew Long11:48 19 Mar 21Tom Masters with McMichael Insurance was very responsive to our insurance needs and presented a coverage plan for auto, home, and umbrella that was very cost competitive with... solid coverage. When we had questions about coverage Tom was quick to respond and patient in his explanations.read moreMary Summers20:09 03 Mar 21The McMichael Insurance Agency team has been with our small business from day one. They have helped us grow from a small preschool to a five center corporation over the past 12... years. Tom, Julie and the team are always there for our many, many questions. They insure that we have the appropriate coverage to operate and keep our company, staff and over 200 students safe. They are truly a vital part of our Here For You Preschool and Child Development Center family. We recommend them every chance we get!read moreCarol Soehnlen19:06 08 Feb 21Over a number of years, our agent, Tom Masters, has helped our business find insurance coverage for a number of normally uninsurable activities. He is very personable and it is... nice to be able to reach him with questions or concerns in a timely manner.read moreEd Welshenbaugh02:06 27 Jan 21It is so nice to be able to call our agent, have our questions answered with no drama, no worry. They work for us to get the best product for our needs at a competitive price.... Highly recommendedread moreRuth Ham20:51 28 Oct 20Karen was a true professional. Being in sales for over 33 years it was refreshing to find a conscientious agent with great follow-up. I found her to be thorough, prompt, but... still considerate to my financial needs. Thank you for everything Karen!!!read moreNi Doh Htoo15:56 04 Oct 20My and my family have been with McMichael for 5+ years now, and they try to find the best rate for us on auto and home insurance. They get back to you as soon as possible either... by email or phone. Great agent if you are looking for an insurance agent.read moreMichelle Tucker15:13 01 Oct 20McMichael Insurance Agency is very fair, friendly and they processed my accident a few years back very fast and without much effort from me at all. I have been very happy with... their service and their rates ever since I joined them 2 + years ago. I highly recommend them.read moreJohn Paglia13:22 03 Sep 20You know when I (we).. need you..... you are there!!! Thank you for being there when I..... (WE)... need your help or just to answer a question. Just understanding the... problem ....whit on problem!!! Thank you, Johnread moreLizzie McNeill15:54 29 Aug 20My agent at McMichael insurance, Tom Masters, is always very helpful and quick to respond whenever I have questions or concerns. Insurance is not my thing, but Mr. Masters is... always very helpful and understanding. 10/10 recommend.read moreJennifer Laria22:57 24 Aug 20Our family has been with this agency for years and have always received excellent customer service. Karen is our agent she is always pleasant and helpful. She works with us to... find the best product to fit our needs and budget. I would highly recommend them. .read moreBON Zoe19:41 19 Jul 20I have been with McMichael Agency for 15 years & I love it. They are professional, efficient, & always trying to find me the best deal. I love being able to email them with... questions. I love the portal also for viewing my plans & documents & making payments. I feel like I am in very good hands, They look out for my best value.read moreJason VerSluys16:41 05 Jul 20Been working with them last 18 years and they keep us on top of our business insurance needs along the wayHope Fuller16:35 01 Jul 20Best insurance agency I’ve ever used! Debbie is always helpful and answers all my questions. She also checks and makes sure I am getting the best rate. In fact she just saved us... $200 a month! I recommend McMichael Insurance to everyone.read moregmw1200 GW14:19 23 Jun 20They will find you the least expensive insurance. They continually look for a better deal for you.Rose Knox01:12 20 Jun 20The office staff are always professional and have resolved any problems we’ve had for probably the last 20 years at least.Glenda DeHoff14:18 18 Jun 20My agent helped me select the best Medicare Advantage Plan. He was knowledgeable and helpful.Gary Habegger15:27 17 Jun 20Very professional and helpful service. McMichael Insurance Agency is very responsive to client's needs.Eric Massanyi15:12 17 Jun 20Tom has always handled our insurance needs promptly and is very helpful when needed.Cora Perez18:06 16 Jun 20When the Braun Agency sold to McMichael. the transition was without problem. They have maintained fair rates. They contacted me when I was near Medicare eligeable time and an... agent assisted me in choosing a Medicare advantage plan that would meet my needs at no cost for the service. I haven't had any claims so I can't evaluate that, but overall I'm happy with the Agency.read moreDana Westfall17:37 21 May 20The staff is completely wonderful especially Julie. I never have to wait long for a call back if they are at lunch and really does make sure you get the best deals out there for... your family!read moreDan Gann16:03 20 May 20We were out of state when our windshield was cracked by a stone thrown up by a truck. Received great service on what to do if it became necessary to get it repaired before we... returned home.read moreDaniel & Rosemary Koch16:33 10 May 20Friendly staff, and always ready to answer questions when needed. Thanks for the great service!Christiana Moll02:45 10 May 20Dealing with McMichael Insurance has been a great experience. Their staff is knowledgeable, they offer great service and they were able to save us money on our home and auto... insurance without sacrificing coverage limits.read moreBeth Hudak02:36 02 May 20We have been with McMichael for a few years now and couldn't be happier with the customer service and price! Thank you!Cassie Hubbard14:37 28 Apr 20McMichael Insurance has been so helpful! Debbie is always looking out for the best deal on auto insurance for me. I could not be happier with the service they provide.Connie Morton23:42 27 Apr 20Grange has been our family's insurance all of my life. It could have started with my grandparents but I know for sure my parents and my husband's parents have always had Grange... insurance.The McMichael Agency has been very accommodating with changes, updates and with cancellations due to death. They answer all my questions even when I ask them the same one several times.I have always recommended Grange insurance even when it may not be the cheapest it's the best and the McMichael Agency cares about us.Connie Mortonread moreCaroline Willoughby14:46 24 Apr 20Always quick to respond to a question, and very willing to explain if I don't understand something.Frank Cilona15:42 13 Apr 20I have been very happy with the McMichael Insurance Agency for my insurance needs. They are very professional yet personal. I think that's important for an insurance company.Gage Kimble14:40 12 Apr 20fantastic service been with them since i was 16. super fast and always professional. saved me a ton of money over the years. life long customer.Brenda Benson18:03 05 Apr 20To whom it may concern,I am very thankful for McMichael Insurance Agency. They have helped me time and time again. Debbie Craft is my agent and she works hard to help me find... the best plan for my insurance; homeowner’s and auto insurance. She is available and returns my calls either the day I call or the next day. When she was out from her accident, other staff took care of my insurance needs and did a great job, too.I’m quite satisfied with the way they run the agency. When I lived in my mobile home, I turned in some claims and they and Progressive Insurance took care of everything.I am pleased with the service I receive from this agency. I would recommend this agency to my family and friends.Take care everyone and be safe & healthy.Brenda Bensonread morevance rosler17:09 03 Apr 20We have been very happy with the service we have received at McMichael Insurance agency. Our agent is professional, quick to respond to questions, and so easy to work with.Amy Miklos14:50 18 Mar 20My agent, Julie H. in Hartville, Ohio, was incredibly helpful in establishing my business insurance for an organic business (with relatively unknown risk factors.) She was the... consummate professional, following up when I was insanely busy with my start up, and providing the required insurance (by my Landlord) at an extremely affordable rate. I highly recommend not just this insurance company, but this particular agent.read more
Select Page