File a Claim

During normal business hours, please call us to ensure that you maximize your claim payment. After hours, if it is an emergency please contact your insurance provider.

The following claim reporting numbers have been provided for your convenience. They can be used 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.

Please note: When you need to report a claim after business hours or on weekends, please listen to the full message and follow the prompts carefully. In order to save time and ensure the best claim service possible, please be sure to have your policy number available and as much detailed information about the claim as possible.

Acuity 800-242-7666
AonEdge 800-370-4524
ASI 866-274-5677
Auto-Owners 888-252-4626
Berkshire Hathaway
Branch 833-427-2624
Cincinnati 877-242-2544
Clearcover 855-444-1875
CNA Surety 877-672-6115
Coterie 855-680-2440
Cowbell Cyber 833-633-8666
Elephant 800-413-8860
Encompass 800-588-7400
Foremost Star
Grange 800-445-3030
Hanover 800-628-0250
Hastings Mutual 800-442-8277
Kansas City Life 800-821-6164
Lemonade 844-733-8666
Liberty Mutual 844-325-2467
Markel Insurance 800-362-7535
National General 800-462-2123
Nationwide 800-421-3535
Openly 888-808-4842 800-564-1799
Philadelphia 800-765-9749
Progressive 800-274-4499
Safeco 800-332-3226
State Auto 877-722-5246
The Hartford 800-243-5860
Policies beginning with VFMK:


Policies beginning with IBL:


Travelers 800-252-4633
West Bend Mutual 877-922-5246
Western Reserve Group 800-362-0426
Westfield Insurance 800-637-3846
If you do not see your insurance company listed, please send us an e-mail and provide your claim information. Be sure to include as much basic information as you can.

An agency representative will contact you as soon as possible.

A complete list of email addresses can be found on our Contact page.